Dickinson

Hailee Steinfeld

Emily Dickinson

Toby Huss

Edward Dickinson

Adrian Enscoe

Austin Dickinson

Anna Baryshnikov

Lavinia 'Vinnie' Dickinson

Ella Hunt

Sue Gilbert

Jane Krakowski

Mrs. Dickinson

Chinaza Uche

Henry

Sophie Zucker

Abby Wood

Kevin Yee

Toshiaki

Gus Birney

Jane Humphrey

Allegra Heart

Abiah Root

Darlene Hunt

Maggie

Amanda Warren

Betty

Samuel Farnsworth

George Gould

Finn Jones

Samuel Bowles

Robert Picardo

Ithamar Conkey

Pico Alexander

Henry 'Ship' Shipley

Erin Gerasimovich

Anna

Neville Lee

Clara

Will Pullen

Nobody

Gabriel Ebert

Thomas Wentworth Higginson

Ayo Edebiri

Hattie

Wiz Khalifa

Death

Nore Davis

Solomon

Myles Alexander Evans

Erasmus

Tristan Griffin

Everett

Wavyy Jonez

The Wall

Curt Morlaye

Michael River Jordan

Gus Halper

Joseph Lyman

Matt Lauria

Ben Newton

Joey Odom

Archibald

Max Chernin

Samuel Strong

Jessica Hecht

Aunt Lavinia

Jamel Davall Rodriguez

Freddie

Levi Ricks

Helen

Jason Mantzoukas

Bee (voice)

Warren Katz

Minister

Teddy Bergman

Daniel Bliss

Merritt Chase

Union Officer (uncredited)

John Mulaney

Henry David Thoreau