Little White Lie

Enola Finlay

Sami Reese

Christopher Sandberg

Duder Reese

Lauren Lopez

Tanya Freemont

Darren Criss

Toby Phillips

Jim Povolo

Jim

Tony Pisaneschi

Love Grenade #1

Mar Hrecznyj

Love Grenade #2

Trevor Smith

Love Grenade #3

Meredith Stepien

Meredith / Hot Girl #1 / Hot Girl #3

Mark Swiderski

Love Grenade #4

Brian Holden

Zack

Rita Khori

Alexa

Malcolm Tulip

Nigel Waters

Nick Lang

Kevin Bushwald

Aaron Seeburger

Hunkytonk #1 / Student #1

Jaime Becharas

Hot Girl #1 / Hot Girl #2 / Hot Girl #3

Spencer Perrenoud

Ex-Boyfriend #2 / Ex-Boyfriend #3 / Ex-Boyfriend #4

Mitch Voss

Hunkytonk #2 / Hunkytonk #3 / Student #2

Danny Mooney

Ex-Boyfriend #2 / Ex-Boyfriend #1

Kyle Colton

Ex-Boyfriend #3 / Ex-Boyfriend #1 / Ex-Boyfriend #2

Amy Buno

Hot Girl #2 / Hot Girl #3 / Student #3

David Henning

Ex-Boyfriend #1 / Ex-Boyfriend #2

Barbra Shaheen

Amelia Bushwald

Sari Brown

Kevin's Friend

Grant Anderson

Hunkytonk #3 / Party Goer #2

Liam White

Hunkytonk #2

Alyssa Gale

Student #2 / Party Goer #3

Lindsay Blackwell

Student #6 / Student #2

Sean O'Reilly

Student #7 / Student #3

Adam Lorenz

Student #5

Hanna Zeman

Student #3 / Party Goer #4

Matt Lang

Student #1 / Customer

Leigh Woods

Terry Reese

Sharif Nasr

The Heckler

John Neville-Andrews

Arthur Kingsley

Brad Vetrone

Party Goer #1

Casey Zamler

Hot Girl #3

Eric Kahn Gale

Hunkytonk #3

Bill Lang

Meditator #1

Michelle Yablans

Student #4 (as a different name)