Jenny

Jenny McCarthy

Jenny McMillan

Heather Dubrow

Maggie Marino

Dale Godboldo

Cooper

George Hamilton

Guy Hathaway

Rafer Weigel

Max

Richard Libertini

Mr. Patel

Kevin Ruf

Ted Tucker

Carolyn Hennesy

Chase Gardner

Michael Rivkin

Weasly Man

Ken Hanes

Bachelor #2

Dan Bucatinsky

Carl

Miriam Flynn

Mother Superior

Katie Hagan

Maggie at 8

Lindze Letherman

Jenny at 8

Eric McCormack

Jason Slade

Marty Simpson

Jenny (singing voice)

Marcia Ann Burrs

Minnesotan Woman

Mike Grief

Piercing Expert #1

Karen Kilgariff

Sales Clerk

Kathleen MacDonald

Woman #2

Christopher Maleki

Ian

Meredith Monroe

Brianna

Alex Nevil

Daryl

Susan Sherriffe

Woman #1

Bill Stevenson

Piercing Expert #2

Arden James

Scarlet (uncredited)

Leon W. Grant

Man

Darla Haun

Emaline

Seth Isler

Jake

Natasha Pavlovich

Cosmonaut

Ray Proscia

Drug Dealer

Sean Whalen

Writer

Shannon Marie Bullock

Waitress

Vicki Davis

Girl Captain

Cathy DeBuono

Woman #1

Robyn Hyden

Girl

Katie Rich

Amanda

Rick Hearst

Zak

Tempestt Bledsoe

Kaylene

Mike Doyle

Dave