It Happened in Flatbush

Lloyd Nolan

Frank 'Butterfingers' Maguire

Carole Landis

Kathryn Baker

Sara Allgood

Mrs. 'Mac' McAvoy

William Frawley

Sam Sloan

Robert Armstrong

Danny Mitchell

Jane Darwell

Mrs. Maguire

George Holmes

Roy Collins aka Roy Anderson

Scotty Beckett

Squint

Joseph Allen

Walter Rogers

James Burke

Umpire Shaunnessy

Roger Imhof

Mr. Maguire

Matt McHugh

O'Doul

LeRoy Mason

J.C. Scott - Catcher

Pat Flaherty

Pat O'Hara - Pitcher

Dale Van Sickel

Stevenson - First Baseman

John Burger

Jim Harding - Outfielder

Jed Prouty

The Judge

Robert Homans

Mr. Collins

Mary Gordon

Mrs. Collins

Ruth Clifford

Ruth (uncredited)

Heinie Conklin

Team Trainer (uncredited)

Gino Corrado

Paul (uncredited)

Bess Flowers

Patron at Pegasus Club (uncredited)

Jack Gargan

Reporter (uncredited)

Bud Geary

Blind Man (uncredited)

Rondo Hatton

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Robert Emmett Keane

Team Co-Owner (uncredited)

Mae Marsh

Aunt Mae (uncredited)

Bert Moorhouse

Reporter (uncredited)

Harry 'Snub' Pollard

Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)

Alexander Pollard

Butler (uncredited)

Dick Rich

Leo (uncredited)

Blue Washington

Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Fred Aldrich

Burly Baseball Fan

Hal Berger

Announcer