The Legend of Bloody Mary

Paul Preiss

Ryan

Robert J. Locke

Father O'Neal

Nicole Aiken

Nicole

Brittany Miller

Jen

Rachael Taylor

Amy

Caitlin Wachs

Mary Worth

Stephen Macht

Magistrate

Irina Costa

Rachel

Cooper Campbell

Clair

Joseph Domingo

Detective Romano

Elissa Dowling

Mary Winters

Dean O'Gorman

Reverend Whittaker

Kristen Dalton

Maggie

Joseph Battaglia

Young Ryan

Joe Hendrick

Roommate

Randy Mulkey

Governor Holbrook

Chris Blasman

Rev. Samuel Blake

Matt Huhn

Governor's Assistant

Sandi Tucker

Girlfriend (as Sandra Tucker)

Mike Nelson

Construction Worker

Jackie Kreisler

Mary Worth Corpse

Merissa Principal

Mary Worth Corpse (as Merissa Principal)

Grant Sawyer

Security Guard

Gabriella Lamb

Maggie's Mom

Frank Iatarola

Teacher

LeLand Washington

Rob (as Leland Washington)

Dianne Curwick

Mrs. Whittaker (uncredited)

Clifford Bañagale

Cafe guy (uncredited)

Lauren Phillips

Ashley